The Guilty Party: Unloading the Burden of Asian Guilt

While this article uses the encompassing term “Asian,” the author recognizes and acknowledges that Asia is geographically expansive with diverse social and cultural variations, and that not all individuals’ experiences within the vast Asian diaspora may align with those described.

Rooted in collectivism and filial piety, “Asian Guilt” describes a specific and nuanced set of shame and guilt induced by familial expectations. For many, unloading the burden of Asian guilt can be a complicated and seemingly inconceivable task—after all, is it possible to free yourself from any form of expectations and norms without facing the consequences of isolation, abandonment, and ostracization… let alone ones that are enforced by the culture itself? 

This article intends to provide foundational information to help you understand Asian guilt and considerations that can help you unload the burden of it. 

Cultural Determinants of Asian Guilt

Influenced by Confucianism, many Asian cultures emphasize group orientation, interpersonal harmony, acceptance of authority, and the importance of scholastic achievement. With that, shame is conceptualized as a motivator that informs Asian individual’s thoughts and actions—which results in their tendency to carry the burden of their community’s image (e.g., when one achieves well, the rest of the community shares their honor; when one fails, they bring shame to their community.) Furthermore, with a highlight on familial relationships and bonds, Asian children often carry the weight of fulfilling their parents', grandparents', and their ancestors’ hopes, dreams, and aspirations. 

Based on the sociocultural factors above, Asian guilt can manifest within family systems. Children learn from a young age the concept of “saving face” (one’s face can be understood as their reputation or public stature), as one is expected to do and achieve as much as possible as a means to avoid “losing face,” which leads to a deep feeling of humiliation for letting down family and themselves. In fact, many Asian and Asian American clients I’ve worked with often describe experiences of being compared to siblings, cousins, and “other family’s children” by their parents, which adds a layer of pressure to perform up to unrealistic standards. 

Impact and Implications of Asian Guilt

With a fixation on shame and the prioritization of collective image above personal interest, the consequences of Asian guilt can be steep. To name a few, negative self-concept comes as a common cost since shame informs individuals of a negative evaluation of themselves—this can lead to low self-esteem, insecurity, anxiety, and depression. Next, as individualization within Asian cultures can sometimes be viewed as a selfish act, Asian guilt can manifest as an inability to identify and meet personal needs and a weakened sense of self-identity. Lastly, since personal failures are “not so personal” in Asian culture, individuals often develop maladaptive perfectionistic ideals. They may not be as willing to be vulnerable with others—especially regarding personal struggles and inadequacies. So, instead of vocalizing personal needs and asking for support, Asians have a higher tendency to choose to suffer silently due to their fear of social stigma. 

Now that you’ve been equipped with background knowledge about Asian guilt, you may be wondering, what can I do about it? 

Personal liberation is precisely as it sounds—personal! Though there are shared experiences among Asians, each individual’s lived experiences, the meaning drawn from them, and the way Asian guilt manifests in their day-to-day can look very different. So, while this article cannot provide the exact roadmap for your healing, here are things you may consider exploring: 

Reframe Your Personal Narrative: While there is beauty in the interconnectedness within a collectivistic community, some of its cultural values can influence our individual self-concept. In my clinical work, I notice that clients from collectivistic cultural backgrounds have the tendency to identify themselves in terms of their roles and social relationships (e.g., I am a good/bad parent, sibling, friend, partner, etc.), which can be reductive, rather than their personality traits (e.g., I am kind, smart, brave, shy, funny, ambitious, skeptical, etc.) There aren't any inherent issues with this way of viewing yourself. However, applying the duality of good vs. bad to our roles can create rigidity around your self-perception. Rewriting the narrative of who you are can help you evaluate yourself differently. 

💡Tip: Next time you find yourself reflecting on a mistake, especially one you feel guilty for, instead of saying,“I am a bad (ex: son, daughter, etc.) ,” try saying, “I was being (ex: careless, pessimistic, impulsive, etc.) , and I will try my best to do better next time.” This can help create space between your self-identity and your mistakes. 

Identify Personal Core Values: Learning about your personal values can provide a meaningful sense of direction in life. When it comes to dealing with Asian guilt, you may find yourself feeling an urge to conform to certain ideals, behaviors, and expectations. However, being in tune with your values can help you identify what decisions truly serve your higher purpose and goals and equip you with the voice of reason and security as you combat guilt trips. 

💡Tip: Think about these questions and consider why… 

• What is important to you? 

• What are the most meaningful moments of your life? 

• What are the most dissatisfying moments in your life? 

• What stories and narratives inspire and move you? 

• What gives you hope? 

• What makes you angry? 

• What accomplishments are you most proud of? 

Understanding the Source & Cost of Your Guilt: In my clinical work, most clients identify parents and social pressure as the source of their guilt. However, to paint a fuller picture, consider what other sources of guilt may be present in your life, then think about how your sense of guilt has influenced the behavioral patterns you want to address. 

💡Tip: Jot down some of the choices and decisions in your life that were influenced by your guilt. Take time to reflect on whether there is a repeated pattern behind these choices and whether they align with your values. Try to evaluate what changes you can make to prevent yourself from repeating these patterns, and explore how you feel about these changes. (Note: change is hard, so it is normal if this doesn’t feel great in the beginning!) 

Set & Communicate Personal Boundaries: In my experience, many Asians cannot entirely separate from family units and members who use emotionally abusive tactics that result in Asian guilt. However, you can still set more realistic and appropriate boundaries as you create a more liberated and authentic lifestyle. These may include limiting the time spent with particular family members and the information you share. Boundaries are essential, and there is nothing wrong with expressing your needs as long as they are communicated and maintained in a healthy way. 

💡Tip: Remember that boundaries are meant to protect our physical and emotional health and keep our sense of safety and security intact. Know that you are not a bad person for having these boundaries, even if they are not met with understanding and kindness at times. 

Seek Support & Collective Healing: Guilt can show up as an uncomfortable feeling that may trigger other negative emotions. However, it is a healthy emotion that informs us of wrongdoings when appropriate, and the goal isn’t to fully remove it from our lives but to be able to experience it in a balanced and helpful way. Sharing your feelings with close individuals who provide a sense of security can be comforting in your process, and hearing from others who may share similar experiences can be validating! 

💡Tip: As mentioned earlier in this article, your Asian guilt may be a part of the hesitation to seek help, whether from loved ones or a therapist. Remember that it is normal for all humans to have needs, and you don’t have to suffer silently! 

—

Interested in exploring your Asian Guilt in therapy? Reach out for a free consultation today!